A 1031 exchange can defer the tax on the depreciation you have claimed on an investment property, along with the rest of your gain, as long as you trade into like-kind real property and take nothing else out. That deferral has limits, and they matter most for owners whose buildings went through a cost segregation study. If you plan to sell a depreciated rental or commercial building and buy the next one through an exchange, these are the rules that decide whether recapture lands on this year’s return.
As co-founder of Seneca Cost Segregation and a real estate investor myself, I’ve worked with owners who reach us in the window between selling one property and closing on the next. The assumption we hear most often from clients and CPAs at that stage is that an exchange makes recapture disappear. The reality of how recapture works is that a full exchange postpones most of it, while the components a study moved onto shorter schedules follow a separate rule that can create ordinary income even when no cash changes hands.
Below, I cover what a full exchange defers, which kinds of recapture can still be triggered, the IRS’s own worked examples, how cost segregation plays out on both properties, what finally ends the deferral, and where the numbers go on your return.
TL;DR — 1031 Exchange Depreciation Recapture
Here is what an exchange does with the depreciation you have already deducted.
- ●Straight-line depreciation on the building rolls forward: in a full exchange, the gain it created moves into the replacement and is taxed at a maximum 25% rate only when you eventually recognize it.
- ●No boot does not always mean no tax: in an IRS Publication 544 example, an exchange with no cash and $0 of recognized gain still produces $10,000 of ordinary income from section 1245 components.
- ●Bonus on qualified improvement property has a softer limit: in an IRS example with no cash and $200,000 of section 1250 property received, that recapture drops to $0 and attaches to the new building.
- ●Furniture and equipment sit outside the exchange: only real property is like-kind, so gain on movable personal property sold with the building is taxed in the year of the sale.
- ●Component values at sale set the size of the bill: section 1245 recapture is figured on the components themselves, so a supportable sale price allocation matters as much as the exchange.
- ●A transfer at death ends the chain: both recapture sections exclude transfers at death, and the heir’s basis resets to fair market value.
How a 1031 Exchange Defers Depreciation Recapture
An exchange in which you receive only like-kind real property recognizes no gain, and most of the gain your depreciation created goes unrecognized with it.
IRS Publication 544 states that the like-kind nonrecognition rules apply only to exchanges of real property held for investment or for productive use in a trade or business. When your exchange stays inside those rules and you take nothing else out, the depreciation on the building has no recognized gain to attach to this year. The exceptions come from depreciation and property that fall outside that simple picture.
Unrecaptured Section 1250 Gain on the Building
Most of the depreciation on a typical rental building is straight-line, and straight-line depreciation on a building is never recaptured as ordinary income. Section 1250(b)(1) defines the “additional depreciation” subject to ordinary recapture as depreciation beyond the straight-line amount for property held more than one year, and residential rental property runs on a 27.5-year straight-line schedule under IRS Publication 946, with nonresidential real property on 39 years.
The gain that straight-line depreciation creates is unrecaptured section 1250 gain. IRS Topic 409 says it is taxed at a maximum 25% rate when it is recognized, and in a full exchange it is deferred along with the rest of your gain.
Where the Deferred Recapture Goes
The depreciation you claimed stays embedded in the basis of the property you receive. Under section 1031(d), the replacement starts from the basis of the property you gave up, decreased by any money you received and increased by any gain you recognized.
With your old, depreciated basis as the starting point, the deferred gain and the depreciation behind it travel into the new building. Publication 544 says so directly for section 1250 ordinary recapture an exchange shelters: the recapture attaches to the property acquired and is recognized when you later sell or dispose of that property at a gain.
Which Recapture a 1031 Exchange Can Still Trigger
Four situations can put recapture on this year’s return even when the exchange itself is valid.
| Source of recapture | How it is taxed when recognized | What a full exchange does |
|---|---|---|
| Straight-line depreciation on the building | Unrecaptured section 1250 gain, maximum 25% rate | Deferred into the replacement |
| Boot (cash, debt relief, other property) | Recognized gain up to the boot, which can carry recapture character | Taxed to the extent of the boot |
| Section 1245 components from a study | Ordinary income | Can be taxed even with no boot, up to the section 1245(b)(4) limit |
| Bonus on qualified improvement property | Ordinary income under section 1250 | Limited by section 1250(d)(4), which can fall to $0 |
| Movable personal property | Ordinary income on the depreciation portion | Outside the exchange, so the gain is recognized |
Boot Received in the Exchange
Boot is anything you receive that is not like-kind real property: cash, relief from a mortgage you do not replace with new debt or added cash, or other property. Section 1031(b) recognizes your gain up to the amount of that money and the fair market value of the other property.
Recognized gain from boot keeps the character of the property that produced it, so part of it can be recapture. Owners who take cash out of an exchange should model the character of that gain with their CPA before the sale closes.
Section 1245 Components From a Cost Segregation Study
A cost segregation study identifies components of a building that qualify as personal property for depreciation, typically on 5- and 7-year schedules, and those components are section 1245 property for depreciation and recapture. Our comparison of Section 1245 vs 1250 property explains which parts of a building fall in each group.
Many of those components still count as real property for the exchange. Treasury Regulation 1.1031(a)-3 defines real property for section 1031 as land and improvements to land, including structural components such as wiring, plumbing systems, and central heating and air conditioning, and the IRS’s Form 8824 instructions work through an apartment building whose section 1245 assets are real property for section 1031.
The exchange can therefore be fully valid while section 1245(b)(4) measures recapture on those components on its own terms. The calculation section below shows how that plays out.
Bonus Depreciation Taken on Qualified Improvement Property
Qualified improvement property is section 1250 property, and Publication 544 treats bonus depreciation taken on it as producing section 1250 ordinary income recapture. The limit for that recapture under section 1250(d)(4) is the greater of the gain recognized on the exchange or the recapture amount minus the fair market value of the section 1250 property you acquire.
In the Publication 544 version with $40,000 of cash, the limit is $40,000 and the full $10,000 of recapture on the improvements is ordinary income. In the version with no cash and $200,000 of real property received, the limit falls to $0, and the $10,000 attaches to the new property until you sell it at a gain.
Personal Property That Is Not Like-Kind
Section 1031 applies only to real property, so movable items you sell along with the building are outside the exchange. Freestanding furniture and appliances are neither land nor improvements to land, and on a furnished short-term rental that can include every bed, sofa, and television in the unit.
Gain on that property is recognized in the year of the exchange. Because it is section 1245 property, the depreciation portion of that gain is ordinary income.
How to Calculate Section 1245 Recapture in an Exchange
Form 8824 line 21 reduces the section 1245 rule to one comparison: the smaller of the depreciation allowed or allowable on the section 1245 property (up to your realized gain), or the gain recognized on the exchange plus the fair market value of non-section 1245 like-kind property you received.
Publication 544 runs that comparison twice on the same facts.
| Step | Exchange with $40,000 cash | Exchange with no cash |
|---|---|---|
| Property given up (FMV / basis) | $100,000 / $50,000 | $100,000 / $50,000 |
| Property received | $60,000 of real property ($45,000 section 1250, $15,000 section 1245) plus $40,000 cash | $100,000 of real property, including $45,000 of section 1250 property |
| Gain realized | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| Gain recognized under section 1031 | $40,000 | $0 |
| Section 1245 recapture on components with a $10,000 basis and $0 adjusted basis | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Section 1245(b)(4) limit | $85,000 ($40,000 + $45,000) | $45,000 ($0 + $45,000) |
| Ordinary income | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Gain deferred | $10,000 | $40,000 |
The IRS Example With Cash Boot
In the first version, you give up a $100,000 property with a $50,000 basis and receive $60,000 of real property plus $40,000 of cash. The section 1245 components on the property you sold were fully depreciated, so their recapture is $10,000.
The limit is the $40,000 of recognized gain plus the $45,000 of section 1250 property received, or $85,000. The smaller figure, $10,000, is ordinary income, and the remaining $30,000 of recognized gain is carried to Form 4797 or Schedule D.
The IRS Example With No Boot
In the second version, you receive $100,000 of real property and no cash, so the exchange recognizes no gain at all. The limit is still $45,000, the value of the section 1250 property received.
The $10,000 of section 1245 recapture is smaller than that limit, so Publication 544 says you must recognize it as ordinary income and defer the remaining $40,000. That is the result most owners of studied buildings do not expect from an exchange that met every other requirement.
What the Sale Price Allocation Changes
Section 1245 recapture is figured on the components themselves. Publication 544’s computation starts from the lesser of their recomputed basis or the amount realized on them, then subtracts their adjusted basis, so a fully depreciated component that sells for little produces little recapture, and one assigned a high value produces more, up to the depreciation taken.
The limit side also depends on what you receive. When the replacement is a building on land, the value of its non-section 1245 property is often far above the recapture amount, which is why both IRS examples recapture the full $10,000. When we coordinate with CPAs on exchanges of studied buildings, the component values in the original study are the natural starting point for that allocation.
How Cost Segregation Affects Recapture on Both Sides of an Exchange
A study changes the recapture picture on the property you sell and the depreciation picture on the property you buy.
The Property You Are Selling
Recapture on a studied building is the other side of deductions you already took. Those deductions came off ordinary income in the early years of ownership, and section 1245 recapture brings back part of them as ordinary income at sale, so much of the study’s value lies in the years you had use of the tax saved.
Recapture on those components can never exceed the depreciation taken on them. Knowing the exposure before you list the property lets you and your CPA weigh an exchange, an outright sale, or a longer hold with real numbers.
The Property You Are Buying
On the replacement, Treasury Regulation 1.168(i)-6 continues the exchanged basis over the remaining recovery period of the old property and treats any excess basis as newly placed in service. For a used replacement property, Regulation 1.168(k)-2 allows bonus depreciation only on the remaining excess basis, which is generally the part funded with new money or new debt.
That excess basis can take 100% bonus depreciation when the qualifying components are acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025, as our overview of bonus depreciation under the One Big Beautiful Bill explains. A study on the replacement also gives your CPA component-level values for the split between section 1250 and section 1245 property that Form 8824 requires.
When Deferred Recapture Finally Comes Due
Deferral postpones the tax, and two events decide when, or whether, it is paid.
A Taxable Sale of the Replacement Property
If you sell the replacement in a taxable sale, the deferred gain and the depreciation embedded in its basis are recognized then, together with the depreciation you claimed on the replacement itself. Another exchange can push that date out again under the same rules.
Transfers at Death and the Basis Step-Up
Section 1245(b)(2) and section 1250(d)(2) state that recapture does not apply to a transfer at death, except for income in respect of a decedent under section 691. Section 1014(a) then sets the heir’s basis at the property’s fair market value on the date of death.
For an owner who holds through a chain of exchanges, that combination can mean the deferred recapture is never collected. The estate planning around it belongs with your attorney and CPA.
How to Report Recapture From a 1031 Exchange
Form 8824 is where the recapture in an exchange is calculated and the deferred gain is recorded.
The Form 8824 instructions put ordinary income recapture on line 21, carry the rest of the recognized gain from line 22 to Form 4797 or Schedule D, total the two on line 23, and record the deferred gain on line 24. Line 25 is the basis of the like-kind property you received, and lines 25a and 25b split it between section 1250 and section 1245 property in proportion to fair market value.
In the instructions’ example, the party who receives an apartment building with $165,000 of section 1250 property and $55,000 of section 1245 property splits a $175,000 basis into $131,250 and $43,750. Our guide to CPA integration of cost segregation results covers how study figures move onto the depreciation schedule after that.
How Seneca Studies Property on Both Sides of an Exchange
At Seneca, here is what the cost segregation study process looks like for properties moving through a 1031 exchange.
Prior Study and Closing Documents
We start with the study and depreciation schedule for the property you are selling, if one exists, along with the purchase contract, both closing statements, and your exchange agreement. Those records show the depreciation each component group carries and the basis that crosses into the replacement.
Onsite or Virtual Property Tour
You decide whether our engineers walk the replacement property in person or tour it by video. Commercial owners frequently pick the onsite visit and residential owners often find the virtual tour fits, and our page on virtual property tours for cost segregation explains how the remote option works.
Component Values Your CPA Can Use
Our engineers identify everything that makes up the property, assign each component a cost and recovery class, and document the result so your CPA can run the line 21 comparison on the old building and the line 25 split on the new one. With timely collaboration from you, we deliver the study in 5 to 10 business days.
Mistakes That Trigger Recapture in a 1031 Exchange
Each of these mistakes turns deferred recapture into tax owed this year, or leaves the new property’s depreciation unsupported.
- ●Treating a full exchange as a full shelter: section 1245 components can produce ordinary income with no boot; ask your CPA to run the line 21 test before you sign the purchase contract.
- ●Trading a studied building for vacant land: land is not section 1245 property and counts in full toward the limit, so the component recapture comes due; model the exchange before you identify land.
- ●Leaving the component allocation to the closing statement: recapture depends on what those components are worth at sale; agree on a supportable allocation with your CPA in advance.
- ●Forgetting the furniture and equipment: movable personal property is not like-kind and its gain is taxed now; price it separately in the contract.
- ●Skipping the basis split on the replacement: lines 25a and 25b need an allocation between section 1250 and section 1245 property; get component values before the first return on the new property.
- ●Projecting bonus on the whole replacement price: a used replacement can take bonus only on excess basis; ask for an estimate that shows exchanged and excess basis separately.
Frequently Asked Questions
Below are the questions investors ask us most often about recapture when they plan an exchange.
Can I Keep Exchanging to Defer Recapture Indefinitely?+
Yes, as long as each exchange meets the section 1031 rules, the deferred gain and the depreciation behind it keep rolling forward. Recapture a given exchange cannot shelter, such as section 1245 recapture within the line 21 limit or gain on personal property, is taxed in that exchange’s year, and a transfer at death ends the chain without recapture.
Does Recapture Apply If I Exchange Into Vacant Land?+
Often, yes. Land is not section 1245 property, so its full value counts toward the section 1245(b)(4) limit, and recapture on the old building’s section 1245 components is generally recognized up to the depreciation taken on them. Vacant land also contains no section 1250 property, so the section 1250(d)(4) limit cannot absorb ordinary recapture from bonus on improvements either.
Should I Get a Cost Segregation Study on My Replacement Property?+
In many exchanges, yes. The excess basis is treated as newly placed in service and can be studied like any acquisition, and the component values support the section 1250 and section 1245 split on Form 8824, so how much a study adds depends largely on how much excess basis the purchase created.
Can I Study the Replacement Property After the Exchange Closes?+
Yes. A study can be completed in a later year, and a look-back cost segregation study claims the depreciation you missed in the current year through Form 3115 and a section 481(a) catch-up adjustment, with no amended returns.
Does a Reverse Exchange Change the Recapture Rules?+
No. A reverse exchange under the IRS safe harbor is still a section 1031 exchange, so the same section 1245(b)(4) and 1250(d)(4) limits apply. The order of the closings is what changes, and our guide to reverse 1031 exchange rules explains how that sequence works.
Does an Installment Sale Defer Recapture the Same Way?+
No. Section 453(i) requires recapture income under sections 1245 and 1250 to be recognized in the year of the sale, even when the rest of the gain is spread over the payments. An exchange can postpone recapture, while an installment sale only spreads out the gain above it.
What Does a Cost Segregation Study Cost?+
Seneca’s fully engineered residential studies start at about $2,000, and commercial studies are priced on complexity, typically starting at $3,500. Our engineers build the preliminary estimate and proposal for free, you pay only if you move forward, and our guide to what a cost segregation study costs explains what moves a quote.
Why Investors Bring Seneca Into an Exchange
Seneca does cost segregation and nothing else, and the engineers who study your property are our own team, with no sales reps or outside affiliates between you and the people doing the work. Every study passes the same internal review, our Head of Engineering signs off before it reaches your CPA, and audit defense is included.
You work with a dedicated Project Manager, our Engineering team, and an Advisor, with real-time updates as the study moves through each stage. Our team has assessed 10,200+ properties, from small single-family rentals to 120+ unit hotels and 40,000+ square foot office buildings, with zero IRS audits triggered or lost, and we also perform Qualified Production Property (QPP) studies.
For a quick read on the property you are buying, try our cost segregation calculator.
Conclusion
What happens to depreciation recapture in a 1031 exchange comes down to which kind of depreciation you took. Straight-line depreciation on the building rolls into the replacement and waits, bonus on qualified improvement property usually waits as well, and section 1245 components from a study can produce ordinary income in the year of the exchange even with no boot.
None of that makes a study on the old building a mistake. The deductions came early, the recapture is capped at what you deducted, and a transfer at death can end the deferral without recapture, so the planning is about knowing the number before you sign.
When you are ready to plan the study on your replacement property, request a free estimate or run the purchase price through our calculator, and our engineers will show you what the new building can deduct.
